It finally happened. Your all-time favorite Crumbl Cookie flavor just popped back on the menu. You dance an ecstatic jig of joy, thank your lucky stars, and fly right out the door to buy a 12-pack. Maybe two. As you drive your precious haul of Crumbl Cookies back home, the thought occurs to you – just how long do Crumbl Cookies last?
Knowing how long Crumbl Cookies keep for is an important element to consider when deciding how many to buy. I mean, you can always share, but for the (totally understandable) times when you want to keep all those gourmet goodies to yourself, it’s helpful to know how long they last and the best means of storing them.
So, if the thought of your precious cookie bounty going bad fills you with dread, worry not – let’s take a look at how long Crumbl Cookies keep when stored at room temperature, in the refrigerator, and in the freezer as well as the best practices for each type of storage.
How Long Are Crumbl Cookies Good For?
Unlike store-bought cookies, Crumbl Cookies are fresh-baked and lack all those unnecessary preservatives found within shelf-stable cookies. Therefore, these premium delights go bad quicker than those other lower-end, less costly cookies.
Like most gourmet treats, the lifespan of homemade cookies is short. If left out at room temperature, Crumbl Cookies will only last 2 to 3 days. If you’re not eating your Crumbl Cookies immediately, you should consider slipping them in the fridge where they’ll be good for up to a week, or possibly even in the freezer for longer storage.
What Is the Best Way To Store Crumbl Cookies?
The worst place to store fresh-baked cookies is in a cookie jar – ironic, no? So where is the best place to store those lavish Crumbl Cookies? That depends on two things: what kind of cookie it is and how soon you want to eat it.
Chilled vs. Regular Cookie Storage
If your cookies are chilled, like Crumbl’s chilled Pink Sugar Cookie or their heavenly chilled Mint Chip Ice Cream cookie, the best place to store them is in the fridge. For all their regular cookies, you can either store them for a few days at room temperature or in the refrigerator.
Other cookies you likely want to move to the refrigerator for immediate storage include those with perishable toppings or ingredients like cream cheese or fruit products, such as Crumbl’s decadent Strawberry Cheesecake cookie.
Storing Crumbl Cookies at Room Temperature
If planning on eating Crumbl Cookies within 48 to 72 hours of picking them up, keeping the cookies at room temperature is a spectacular choice, so long as the cookies aren’t the chilled type or those which contain perishable ingredients. For best results, store them in an airtight container to prevent hardening or staling and move to a cool and dry location out of direct sunlight.
Storing Crumbl Cookies in the Refrigerator
If your cookies are chilled, contain perishable ingredients, or you aren’t planning on eating them in the next 2 to 3 days, refrigeration will be necessary. To maintain the ideal texture of your cookies, it is best not to store them in the box they came in. Although these Instagramable pink boxes are delightful, they are not airtight. This unsealed storage in a cool, dry refrigerator may make cookies stale faster.
Instead, when refrigerating cookies, move them to an airtight container to lock in freshness. Either a plastic container (like in the photo above) or a sealed storage bag will do. Just remember, if your cookies have delicate toppings, store them in a single layer to maintain their beauty!
Storing Crumbl Cookies in the Freezer
When freezing Crumbl Cookies, extra measures should be taken to ensure freshness. I mean, you don’t want all those cookies you stocked up on going to waste, right? You want to guarantee those scrumptious babies will stay moist and fresh for months.
To maintain optimal freshness, wrap each individual cookie in either foil or plastic wrap. Now take those individually wrapped cookies and store them in a second airtight container. Seem a bit excessive? Trust us – this dual storage technique will stop cookies from drying out or losing flavor.
One savvy Crumbl customer freezes the cookies right in their boxes, removes them when hard, and moves them to freezer bags that she stacks and stores inside airtight freezer containers. Genius!
For more freezing tips on Crumbl’s fancier frosted cookies check out the video:
Cookies stored via this method can last up to 6 months – just remove when ready and thaw frozen cookies by leaving them out at room temperature for an hour or two. In a hurry? Provided your Crumbl Cookies are best served warm and are icing or frosting-free, you can speed things up by microwaving your cookies for 30 seconds or tossing them in the oven for a few minutes. Simply set to 350°F and heat for 3 to 5 minutes.
Storing Crumbl Cookies Couldn’t Be Easier!
That’s the wrap on Crumbl Cookies’ shelf life! All your future Crumbl Cookies can rest assured, they will not be going stale any time soon. You’re armed with the ultimate knowledge of the best methods to store Crumbl Cookies, be they at room temperature, in the refrigerator, or in the freezer.
Looking to eat your cookies right away? Store at room temp out of direct sunlight, heat, and moisture. Trying to extend cookie freshness for a full week? Refrigeration is your friend. Attempting to stash those cookies for as long as possible? Freezer, here we come.
Be the chilled Crumbl Cookies or regular, you now hold the valuable knowledge of appropriate Crumbl Cookie storage. Harness your new power wisely and share it with those who are worthy.
Here are all your crucial Crumbl Cookie questions answered surrounding shelf life and storage.
How Long Do Crumbl Cookies Last at Room Temperature?
Crumbl Cookies will keep just fine at room temperature for 2 to 3 days. This is the best way to store cookies for immediate consumption as you don’t have to worry about your refrigerator or freezer drying them out.
How Long Do Crumbl Cookies Last in the Refrigerator?
When storing Crumbl Cookies in the fridge, they will keep for 7 days. Keep them stored in an airtight container to prevent cookies from becoming dry or crumbly.
How Long Do Crumbl Cookies Last in the Freezer?
If properly wrapped and stored, Crumbl Cookies will stay good for up to 6 months when frozen. Just be sure to double-wrap them for superior storage by first wrapping each cookie in foil or plastic wrap, and secondly moving them to an airtight container or freezer bag.
Can I Fix Stale Crumbl Cookies?
When cookies become hard, you can try refreshing them by wrapping them in a damp paper towel and microwaving them for short intervals. Some have also had success with re-baking Crumbl Cookies for a few minutes. Another unusual tip recommends popping in a slice of fresh bread in your storage container to soften crunchy cookies.
Should I Throw Out Stale Crumbl Cookies?
If your Crumbl Cookies are still within the consumable time frame but have simply gone hard and crunchy, there are quite a few options for repurposing stale cookies, including crumbling them up to work into your own cookie batter, grinding them up to make a pie crust, or even making cookie butter.